The Chicago Symphony Orchestra has just named Riccardo Muti as its new Music Director starting in 2010. My question is, what took them so long?
It’s been more than 40 years since the orchestra had any kind of outstanding charisma, even if its conductor in the orchestra’s golden age, Fritz Reiner, did not.
Georg Solti had a lot of personality, but led the CSO into the age of homogeneity and hype when most of the old great orchestras started to all sound the same - a product of the digital recording era - and the CSO sounded more the same as the rest than the rest. And during Solti’s tenure, the orchestra aged, many players, especially some of the older string players , the deadwood as we call it, on their big fat salaries became over-ripe and lazy, not wanting to retire when they should.
Daniel Barenboim, a phenomenal musician and pianist, began to beef up the roster with some great new players, but the band still never regained it’s unique individuality that Chicago has been waiting for since the Reiner years. And what many mistook for “character” in Barenboim was often closer to buffoonery — much of his stage persona was tiresome affect.
Enter Muti. He exudes charisma - personality. Because he is natural, and talented, and unique. And he’s a bit exotic, a genuine product of his Italian upbringing. From the Italian operas to the world’s greatest orchestras, everything he’s done in the last decades, especially La Scala and Phildelphia, sparkles. And it’s organic and honest. He is Toscanini all over again, but without all the excess baggage, does not have the unmanageable, outrageous personality, and he understands the modern orchestral environment.
I am so excited, I can’t wait to get my first tickets in 2010 when he takes over! And now I wish I had practiced more fifteen, twenty years ago and had had a successful audition to join this orchestra. The next ten years have the potential to be one of the Chicago Symphony’s greatest decades. Just watch.